
The Enduring Appeal and Elusiveness of Dark Fairytale Games

By Hideo Kojima


By Hideo Kojima
From the dawn of civilization, stories have served as essential tools for imparting life lessons and survival strategies, warning against deceitful characters, suspicious offerings, and solitary journeys into the unknown. This fundamental human need for narrative now extends into the realm of video games, which, much like traditional literature, offer profound insights into the human condition and the complexities of the world. Yet, surprisingly few games delve into the vast and enchanting world of classic fairytales, an oversight that diminishes the potential for unique interactive experiences.
The original American McGee's Alice, launched in late 2000 by Electronic Arts, captivated audiences with its distinctly dark and unsettling take on Lewis Carroll's beloved Wonderland. Earning an 'M' rating for its disturbing content, this game was a stark departure from more conventional interpretations, offering a Wonderland corrupted from within. Alice's return to this familiar yet profoundly altered realm demanded an unforeseen level of courage and resilience, challenging players to confront psychological horrors and restore order to a shattered world. Its critical acclaim, reflected in an 85 Metacritic score, solidified its place as a groundbreaking title, later becoming accessible on PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 as DLC in 2011.
Following its predecessor, Alice: Madness Returns debuted in June 2011, continuing Alice's journey through a twisted Wonderland. While critics offered a mixed reception, citing issues with combat mechanics and dated visuals, players largely embraced the game's compellingly dark atmosphere and its inventive reinterpretations of the classic tale. Despite the critical divergence, the sequel garnered a dedicated fanbase who appreciated its unique aesthetic and narrative depth.
Since 2014, the dark rendition of Alice has largely receded from public consciousness, overshadowed perhaps by other adaptations. Nevertheless, the existing games continue to beckon players back to their fantastical realms. Unfortunately, accessing these titles has become increasingly difficult. While Alice: Madness Returns remains available for purchase on Steam, its predecessor, American McGee's Alice, has largely disappeared from modern digital storefronts, leaving newcomers without a direct path to the series' origin unless they possess an older digital copy or are willing to navigate complex workarounds.
The current unavailability of these influential games on contemporary console platforms represents a missed opportunity. Both titles could immensely benefit from updated visuals and quality-of-life enhancements, bridging the gap between their original release and today's gaming standards. Such a revitalization would not only address their aged aesthetics but also introduce a new generation of players to the captivating allure of dark fairytale magic, ensuring that Alice's bloody, yet brilliant, adventures remain a vibrant part of gaming history.
About the author

Auteur game designer known for the "Metal Gear" series, blending complex narratives with gameplay.

by Shigeru Miyamoto
by Reiner Knizia