
Josh Brolin Reflects on 'Whalefall' Emotional Resonance and 'Sicario 3' Development

By Roger Ebert


By Roger Ebert
Josh Brolin recently offered insights into the deeply personal and emotionally charged narrative of his latest film, 'Whalefall,' where he portrays Mitt Gardiner, a character whose complex relationship with his son forms the core of the story. Brolin shared how the film's themes resonated with his own life, evoking profound reflections on parenthood and the legacy passed down through generations. Beyond 'Whalefall,' he also provided eagerly anticipated updates on the progression of 'Sicario 3,' confirming that an "undeniable" script has been secured, paving the way for the return of beloved characters and intense cinematic action.
In 'Whalefall,' Mitt Gardiner's decision to end his life by plunging into the ocean, following a mesothelioma diagnosis, sets a somber tone for the film. His estranged son, Jay, played by Austin Abrams, subsequently embarks on a perilous journey to recover his father's remains, hoping to bridge the chasm that separated them. This quest takes an unexpected turn when Jay finds himself trapped inside a sperm whale, an ordeal that forces him to confront his father's unconventional teachings and the profound influence they had on his life.
Brolin's portrayal of Mitt is imbued with a raw honesty, as he grapples with a parenting style driven by a desire to equip his son for life's challenges, even if it meant imposing harsh realities. This approach inadvertently pushed Jay away, leading him to pursue a life far removed from the ocean his father cherished. The actor revealed that his own experiences as a father and son deeply informed his performance, allowing him to connect with the material on a visceral level, particularly regarding the complex interplay between a parent's intentions and a child's independent path.
The symbolic presence of the whale in 'Whalefall' underscores Mitt's overwhelming legacy and the weight of his expectations on Jay. Director Brian Duffield ingeniously incorporated Brolin's actual heartbeat into the film's sound design, making it the literal rhythm of the leviathan, further solidifying the metaphor. This creative choice adds another layer of emotional depth, illustrating how Mitt's influence, even in his absence, continues to guide and challenge his son.
Looking ahead, Brolin confirmed that 'Sicario 3' is finally moving forward, with a script from Steven Knight that he describes as "incredible" and "undeniable." He expressed enthusiasm about reuniting with co-stars Benicio del Toro and Emily Blunt, and working with director Padraic McKinley. Brolin also hinted at a nuanced evolution for his character, Matt Graver, suggesting that audiences will witness a different, more introspective side of the CIA operative, building on the emotional arc established in 'Sicario: Day of the Soldado.'
The actor's candor extended to discussing the cancellation of his television series 'Outer Range,' which he described as "heartbreaking." Despite the disappointment, Brolin maintains a positive outlook, taking pride in the subsequent successes of his co-stars. He views their flourishing careers as a testament to the show's quality, jokingly referring to it as a "middle finger" to those who decided its fate. This sentiment highlights Brolin's enduring belief in the artistic merit of projects he undertakes and his appreciation for the talent he works alongside.
Brolin's conversations about 'Whalefall' and 'Sicario 3' reveal an artist deeply invested in his craft, who not only embodies his characters but also draws from his personal journey to enrich his performances. His reflections on fatherhood, legacy, and the evolution of his roles offer a compelling glimpse into the mind of a seasoned actor navigating both the challenges and triumphs of a dynamic career.
About the author

Pulitzer Prize-winning film critic whose reviews and essays defined cinema criticism for decades.

by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
by Shonda Rhimes